CannCentral
  • Home
  • Business
    Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

    Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

    Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

    Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

    Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

    Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

    dana-larsen-4-big-problems-with-bcs-new-cannabis-laws

    Dana Larsen: 4 big problems with B.C.’s new cannabis laws

  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • News
No Result
View All Result
CannCentral
  • Home
  • Business
    Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

    Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

    Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

    Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

    Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

    Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

    dana-larsen-4-big-problems-with-bcs-new-cannabis-laws

    Dana Larsen: 4 big problems with B.C.’s new cannabis laws

  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • News
No Result
View All Result
CannCentral
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Sarah Leamon: MPs must ensure that the cure for trial delays in Bill C-75 isn’t worse than the disease

Kirk Smol by Kirk Smol
September 13, 2018
in News
0 0
0
Sarah Leamon: MPs must ensure that the cure for trial delays in Bill C-75 isn't worse than the disease

In just a few weeks, members of Parliament will begin studying a massive Liberal bill introduced earlier this year, Bill C-75, to reform our criminal justice system.

Although it makes a number of different proposals to help modernize and streamline the justice system, one of the main areas that it seeks to reform is preliminary inquiries.

Preliminary inquiries are held in order to determine if there’s sufficient evidence for a criminal matter to proceed to trial. They are not intended to make findings of guilt, but rather to ascertain and evaluate the strength of the Crown’s case against the accused. 

At the end of the inquiry, the judge makes a ruling on whether there is enough evidence to commit the accused to trial. 

Related Post

Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

September 7, 2023
Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

September 6, 2023

Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

September 6, 2023

Dana Larsen: 4 big problems with B.C.’s new cannabis laws

September 4, 2023

As the law currently stands, preliminary inquiries can be held in a wide range of circumstances. Generally speaking, they can be held in circumstances where an accused person elects trial by judge alone or trial by judge and jury. 

In spite of the fact that they are widely available, however, they are rarely used. 

A recent report from the Canadian Bar Association put the frequency of preliminary inquiries at less than five percent of criminal proceedings. Statistics Canada reported the same statistics at 2.8 percent in 2014–15. Preliminary inquiries are on a downward trend.

And the federal government wants to keep this trend going.

Bill C-75 aims to restrict the availability of preliminary inquiries. If it passes, they will only be available for offences committed by adults and punishable by life imprisonment.  The bill also seeks to strengthen the judge’s powers to limit the range of issues that are explored in such inquiries, including the list of witnesses to be called.   

Supporters of these amendments say that restricting preliminary inquiries will help to curb delays in the justice system. 

There is no question that our criminal justice system is severely overburdened—and data indicates that when an accused person elects for a preliminary inquiry, the matter takes an average of 433 additional days to conclude. 

This is on top of the fact that proceedings with preliminary inquiries require more nominal court appearances and a higher number of days in between them, which can also contribute to systemic delay and the squandering of precious judicial resources.

Even in spite of these statistics, though, there are serious reasons to doubt whether these amendments will actually have any positive impact whatsoever on courtroom delays. 

The infrequency at which preliminary inquiries are requested tends to mean that restricting them will not have any tangible impact on judicial proceedings. In this way, the changes contemplated in Bill C-75 may do little more than codify the reality of what is already happening in our courtrooms today. 

There is also some evidence to suggest that restricting these inquiries may actually have the opposite effect of what is intended by Parliament; it may actually contribute to delay. 

This is because preliminary inquiries have proven useful for both Crown and defence counsel. Preliminary inquiries can be used to define issues, gain clarity, and contribute to overall trial efficiency. For example, engaging in a preliminary inquiry can help test witness testimony and determine whether or not a particular witness will even be required at trial. They are also undeniably useful as they allow counsel to gain valuable guidance and insight from a judge. 

By limiting preliminary inquiries, we may be taking a powerful tool away from counsel.

But we also have to consider what we are taking away from the accused. 

People who are accused of a criminal offence have a right to defend themselves, and to do so under the full ambit of the law.  Procedural protections, like preliminary inquiries, should not be done away with so quickly. Instead, we must take under consideration al of the issues at stake—including the rights of an accused person and the important role that such inquiries may play. 

Instead of limiting access to justice by eroding the preliminary inquiry process, the government should rely on other, more practical techniques in order to combat delay and improve trial efficiency. 

For example, judicial vacancies should be filled promptly in order to ensure adequate resources in each and every courtroom.  In the same vein, funding for legal aid programs should be increased and technology should be updated in order to create better access to justice in remote communities and to expedite nominal court proceedings.

After all, the answer to the issue of delay in our criminal justice system does not lie in a single answer. The causes of delay are multiple and varied, and a multifaceted approached should be adopted. 

Limiting preliminary inquiries is unlikely to do little more than compromise the rights of accused people in this country. If our government wants to do something about delay, it should look to more comprehensive methods that do not limit access to justice.Sarah Leamon is a criminal defence lawyer. She also chairs the PACE Society board in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside and holds a master of arts in women’s studies from UBC. Follow her on Twitter @SarahLeamonLaw and find her website here.

Kirk Smol

Kirk Smol

Kirk's journey through the digital realm began with lines of code and algorithms dancing in his dreams. Armed with a keyboard and an insatiable curiosity, he embarked on the path of software engineering. However, fate had a smoky twist in store for him. As the ones and zeros swirled around him, Kirk had an epiphany – he realized that he was more interested in the highs and lows of the cannabis industry than debugging lines of code. With a leap of faith that would make a bungee jumper blush, he bid farewell to the world of semicolons and database queries and embraced the intoxicating allure of cannabis journalism. Now, Kirk finds himself navigating a different kind of network, one that's all about buds, trichomes, and terpenes. Armed with a pen that's mightier than a vaporizer and a keen eye for detail, he's on a mission to unravel the mysteries of the green world.

Related Posts

Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research
News

Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

by Kirk Smol
September 7, 2023
Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate
News

Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

by Kirk Smol
September 6, 2023
Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations
News

Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

by Kirk Smol
September 6, 2023
Next Post
Homeowner claims Maple Ridge property value affected by weed plant across street

Homeowner claims Maple Ridge property value affected by weed plant across street

Recommended

Cannabis compound kills antibiotic-resistant superbug

Cannabis compound kills antibiotic-resistant superbug

January 31, 2019
It’s not a heart attack: chest pain from smoking weed

It’s not a heart attack: chest pain from smoking weed

July 12, 2019
Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

September 6, 2023
Surrey RCMP arrest 18-year-old for cannabis edibles and vaping products

Surrey RCMP arrest 18-year-old for cannabis edibles and vaping products

November 8, 2019
Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research

September 7, 2023
Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate

September 6, 2023
Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

September 6, 2023
dana-larsen-4-big-problems-with-bcs-new-cannabis-laws

Dana Larsen: 4 big problems with B.C.’s new cannabis laws

September 4, 2023
CannСentral Magazine

Recent Posts

  • Bill Blair announces $24.5 million in funding for cannabis research
  • Mary Jean “Watermelon” Dunsdon will run as Vancouver’s cannabis-friendly city council candidate
  • Licensed cannabis producers navigate Health Canada’s marketing and brand regulations

Categories

  • Business
  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • News

© 2023 CannCentral

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Landing Page
  • Buy JNews
  • Support Forum
  • Pre-sale Question
  • Contact Us

© 2023 CannCentral

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In